Will SCOTUS overturn or narrow Stinson deference to federal sentencing-guideline commentary?
As of Wed, 04 Nov 2026 14:50:50 UTC, Kalshi traders price Yes (28.0%). The market has $4K in volume and closes on Tue, 01 Aug 2028.
Updated:
Current odds
| Outcome | Chance | Yes price | No price |
|---|---|---|---|
| Yes | 28.0% | 28.0¢ | 72.0¢ |
Market details
- Venue: Kalshi
- Volume: $4K
- Liquidity: $4K
- Closes:
Resolution rules
If the Supreme Court, in Beaird v. United States, rules courts must independently interpret the Sentencing Guidelines or apply a narrower deference framework than Stinson when considering Guidelines commentary, then the market resolves to Yes. The Payout Criterion for the Contract encompasses the Expiration Values that the Supreme Court of the United States has ruled, in Beaird v. United States, that Stinson v. United States no longer correctly states the rule governing the deference courts must give commentary to the Sentencing Guidelines, including by requiring courts to exercise independent judgment or apply a materially narrower deference framework than Stinson’s rule that such commentary is authoritative unless it violates the Constitution or a federal statute, is inconsistent with the guideline, or is a plainly erroneous reading of the guideline, after Issuance and before August 1, 2028. The market resolves to No if the Court holds that Stinson still correctly states the governing rule. A vacatur or remand resolves to Yes only if accompanied by a merits ruling satisfying the foregoing condition; a dismissal, dismissal as improvidently granted, or remand without such a ruling resolves to No.
Sources
Related markets
- Will Samuel Alito announce his retirement?
- Who will be the next Supreme Court justice in Trump's term?
- Who will be charged with a federal crime this year?
- Who will be arrested this year?
- When will Justice Alito retire from the Supreme Court?
- Democratic Presidential Nominee 2028
More markets like this
- Will SCOTUS reject a benchmark requirement for ERISA fund-underperformance claims?
- Will SCOTUS reject narrow Free Exercise tests for Catholic preschools?
- Will SCOTUS require 12-person juries for serious felonies?
- Will SCOTUS require state-law compensation in private natural-gas condemnations?
- Will SCOTUS recognize a right to possess AR-15-style rifles?
- Will SCOTUS rule for DHS on third-country deportations?
- Will SCOTUS treat trademark strength as a factual question?
- Will the independence of the judiciary be weakened during Trump's term?
- Will Seattle have a Michelin star restaurant in 2025?
- Will Section IV of the 25th Amendment be used during Trump's Presidency?
- Will Senate Democrats vote on their leader before Dec 1?
- Will Serbia announce a snap election?
A price on DOXA is the market-implied probability of an outcome on the venue that lists it. It is what traders are paying, not a forecast made by DOXA, and it is not investment advice. How DOXA shows prices · Terms of Use
DOXA is a liquidity aggregator for prediction markets that compares odds and depth across Polymarket, Kalshi and others and routes each trade for best execution with an AI assistant.